REVIEW: Kaminey

Shahid Kapoor delivers a knockout performance in this Vishal Bhardwaj film
By Anand Vaishnav . Buzz18 Aug 13, 2009
Comments [120]   E-mail

It's the film all of us have been waiting for. Almost everyone I know has already decided that they would love Kaminey – without even seeing the film. Yet one must rate a film for what it is, without being bogged down by slick, promos and the director's past record.

Vishal Bhardwaj’s Kaminey is a one-of-a-kind experience. All those expecting a dark, action-packed entertainer, be warned. This is grittier stuff. Kaminey is the director's tribute to Guy Ritchie, Taratino, Coen Brothers and the entire cult of pulp flicks.

So you've got a film full of crazy gangsters, black humour, intervening sub plots, accidental murders…all leading to a lot of confusion and mayhem. If Burn after Reading was about a gym bag, Kaminey is about a guitar and some pouches of cocaine. Somewhere down the line, Vishal cleverly merges the age-old, double role theme into this chase. The narrative takes its own sweet time to unravel - only to pick up tremendously after the first 30 minutes.

What makes this film special is the writing and detailing. The movie is a multi-cultural, multi-lingual crime thriller with gangsters from every region of India. The director gets all the mannerisms and accents right. And this diversity is what livens up many of the intense conflicts. Vishal's choice of authentic locations further enhances the scenes. Even the graffiti outside the toilets looks completely real.

Like Omkara, Kaminey also works as an ensemble. But it's leading man Shahid Kapoor's moment of glory. The lisping Charlie (Shahid) and stammering Guddu (Shahid) come across as completely different people. Shahid who has been a self-confessed SRK fan will do his idol proud. Charlie has the aggression of Baazigar while Guddu has the innocence of Yes Boss. Shahid also displays nuances of his father's acting. Especially as Charlie, whose intense voice echoes of Pankaj Kapoor's Abbaji. Kapoor should get ready to lap up all the Best Actor awards.

Priyanka Chopra has an interesting role. And she does very well as the simple Maharashtrian girl with wild sexual fantasies. Be it her seductive expressions or angry outbursts, Chopra is a treat to watch. But unfortunately her character is sidelined in the second half. Kaminey also marks a smashing, acting debut for Amol Gupte. Gifted with a menacing screen presence, the creative director of Taare Zameen Par brings back memories of a young Nana Patekar. Amol delivers a standout performance.

Kaminey’s soundtrack is already a chartbuster. But the songs could have been placed better. Vishal’s genius musical sense is actually at full display in his background music. His use of classic Bollywood numbers during the violent fights is simply rocking.

But Kaminey has its downers. Firstly the film is too long. A plot of this genre is never story driven. And it’s always the characters and their confusion that keep you engaged. But there is only this much of confusion that you can take. Also, the proceedings get a bit too heavy on the senses – especially the lengthy, explosive climax.

Vishal Bhardwaj deserves full credit for making a film that has no parallel in Bollywood. There have been attempts to make smart, crime thrillers in the past - But Kaminey achieves a balance between packaging and experimentation.

Verdict: Kaminey is a film that expects you to be attentive. Even though you might need a breather once the lights come on, it certainly is unlike anything that's come out in a long, long time.

Rating:
3.5/5

Bookmark and Share
Click here
comments [120]

This movie simply rocks in all aspects..... Shahid has just
given an outstanding performance in both the roles.. But i
liked guddu alot coz he's very innocent & looks very
sweet........... On the contradary the film is just
superb....Cheers to vishal & shahid......... Shahid
kapoor just rocks....

vinitha Sep 22, 2009 at 05:50 PM

Brilliant direction and superb performances from all the
actors make kaminey an edge of the seat movie that one can
not miss.

himanshu Aug 19, 2009 at 08:44 PM

The movie is one of the best i've ever seen ...It has the
best music i've ever heard and the acting cannot get any
better...And shahid has acted his best in this movie

Neomi Aug 17, 2009 at 06:40 PM

I luved the movie...N i would want every1 to watch it only
at the theaters so that they could experience the beats of
the music n enjoy it...
shahid and priyanka also make a wonderful couple..So
every1 should watch it at the theaters n not through
piracy....

Priya Aug 17, 2009 at 06:38 PM

The movie is jus amazing..I jus came bak from the
theaters...But i m sorry for the people of bombay and pune
who will not get to see it on the day of itz release...But i
would request u all u see the this blockbuster only =at the
theaters as the experience is much better

Natasha Aug 17, 2009 at 06:37 PM

This is one of the best movies i've seen and the enjoyment
can be experienced even better when v watch it at the
theaters...Soo i would advice every1 to watch this at the
theaters only n not by means of piracy

pIA Aug 17, 2009 at 06:35 PM

U cannot miss the opportunity of watching this amazing
blockbuster at the theaters...The sound effects are so
good...Especially dhan te nan...
soo i request all of u not to watch this movie through
piracy...

puja Aug 17, 2009 at 06:34 PM

This movie is one of a kind...It has a very large contrast
of characters which are played very well by the best in the
industry
the director has done his besttand the movie is sooo
capable of geeting 5 stars and an oscar ....

Sanjana Aug 17, 2009 at 06:33 PM

This movie has a wonderful story and the star cast is too
good....The acting is amazing...N i request all those in
bombay and pune to
go to the theatres to watch this blockbuster.....

nikita Aug 17, 2009 at 06:32 PM

I compliment vishal bhradwraj as he actually named the movie
'kaminey' and produced 1 of the best songs in the history of
the industry...
u get gooose bumps and feel like dancing everytime i hear
the songs...

Megha Aug 17, 2009 at 06:31 PM
  



Post Comment
Don't be rude or interrupt others who are having a conversation. Ethnic slurs, personal insults and abuses are rather uncool. Criticise, but know where to draw the line. No point putting in personal details or links, we won't publish them. Try and write in English and please, stick to the point!
Name City
E-mail  
Comment 200 charc max
Disclaimer: All the content posted under the 'Comments' category are made by the readers of Buzz18, unless specified otherwise. Buzz18 is not responsible for the opinions of the readers and the content posted by the readers are not representative of the views and opinions of Buzz18.

Katrina vs Deepika vs Kareena

by jaymil_4042 Tue Feb 09, 2010 01:38 pm

[quote:1xx4bfe8]It's a battle of the hotties...Deepika needs to give a hit in Love Aaj Kal and make . . ..



Katrina Kaif Honored By Assocham

by Mon Feb 08, 2010 03:35 pm

Katrina . . ..



Anu Vaishnavi South Indian acctress in ver hot photos

by Mon Feb 08, 2010 04:07 am

Anu Vaishnavi is one of the Item Song dancers and acctress. Item Songs are very popular in South Ind . . ..



Related BUZZ WORDS